I've considered broaching this topic for four years now, the homeschooling thing. I'm somewhat skittish when it comes to debates, though, and learned early in the game that education choices are much like politics and religion when it comes to the fervor with which opinions are expressed. Like a spooked mare, I canter back into my opinionated stall. Four years later, though, with a little more research and experience and face-flat-falls and teaching-hours logged, I'm ready to stand without wobbly knees and assert.
In choosing to go one direction, I am, by necessity, choosing NOT to go in ten others. This has to be one of the more paralyzing of the realities. It's the curse of the blank canvas, the blinking cursor, and, as I'm being honest here, the spring school enrollment season.
I was milling about with a paper plate of pastries and mimosa in a plastic tumbler when a fellow shower-goer commented on Eden, who was sitting with her baby sister on the couch. "Your daughter is just beautiful! And so responsible and poised! Where does she go to school?"
"Eden?" I replied. "Oh, we don't send her anywhere. Why educate a girl? The less she knows, the better."
Well, perhaps those weren't my exact words. They may as well have been, though, for the look on the face I saw staring back at me when I replied that we homeschool. This was not an expression of interest or surprise or even disgust, but one of bewilderment, perhaps even mild horror.
The thing is, this response wasn't hurtful. Four years in, I'm no stranger to the kinds of opinions, expressed or implied, that the homeschooling conversation elicits. More than anything, it's been an experience in reading my audience and choosing my words carefully. Even if the other half of the conversation is genuinely interested (which isn't always the case,) there's always more backstory to explain how we've reached the path we're walking when it comes to educating our kids. I don't count it a bad thing to learn how to say less and rest in the knowledge that the backstory is there and truth is truth, regardless of whether others understand or agree with it. Alongside this is the knowledge that much of the searching and wrestling along this path is held in common with parents who've chosen other paths.
I remember fondly a time when I didn't think about neighborhood schools versus school-of-choice, Montessori versus traditional classrooms, nine-month versus year-round schedules, English versus Spanish- or Mandarin-Immersion programs, public versus charter versus private. More than that, I didn't think to think about the model of education in general. I grew up attending (and doing fine at) my nearest public school, and the pre-parent me didn't really think about sniffing out another path for our kids. When Eden approached kindergarten age, I, like every other parent in my position, found these decisions and so many others before me. The Next Right Thing, for us, was to pursue a well-rounded education outside the traditional brick-and-mortar institution.
Dear other parents: in stating my reasons for educating my kids, I am NOT JUDGING YOUR DECISION NOT TO HOMESCHOOL YOURS. This whole thing came as a surprise to us, too. I can't wrap it up neatly to state a principle and end the manifesto, either. The choice wasn't presented and then removed; we are called to do the next right thing at every breath. The week in which I write this has included hours of instruction, frustration, researching homeschool defectors and area programs, breakthroughs, and then, just now, my pre-reader bringing me the cereal box and sounding out the word "life." This is HUGE for him.
It's huge for me, too.











